By R.L. Bynum
Three top arena plans of seven options have emerged as Carolina weighs a consequential decision for the future home of Carolina men’s and women’s basketball.
Senior Associate Athletic Director Rick Steinbacher revealed the top options on Wednesday on the second episode of “The Arena Discussion” podcast.
The frontrunners:
— A major renovation of the 38‑year‑old Smith Center (estimated cost of $591 million, with an annual net cash flow of $4 million).
— A new arena at Odum Village (estimated cost of $703 million, with annual net cash flow of $25 million)
— A new arena at the planned Carolina North campus (estimated cost of $786 million with an annual net cash flow of $26 million)
The renovation option carries major complications, including heavily restricted seating during construction, temporary facilities and difficult decisions about where the team would play if the building becomes unusable for stretches.
“There’d be significant revenue cost to that,” Steinbacher said. “You’re spending a lot of money on things that won’t be in the finished product.”
The four other options are to repair the Smith Center (estimated total cost of $153,050,000), a new arena at the Smith Center site ($782,280,000), an arena at the Bowles Lot ($673,385,000) and an arena at the Friday Center ($741,630,000).
The Smith Center holds 21,750 seats, the largest regularly sold‑out building in college basketball. A new arena is projected to seat between 16,200 and 17,700, trading capacity for comfort with wider seats, expanded concourses, additional restrooms, and more premium amenities.
More than 6,000 seats are tied to permanent seat rights and endowment donors, making any change, new or renovated, a sensitive negotiation. In a new arena, existing seat rights would not transfer automatically, though the Rams Club would work to find parallel options.
UNC has poured resources into the question for years, commissioning architects, financial planners and firms specializing in both new-arena construction and legacy-venue renovation. Carolina has invested $1.3 million in studies examining everything from ticketing projections to traffic flow to where the Tar Heels would play during a potential Smith Center overhaul.
Carolina studied how long it would take fans to drive away from the arena after a game and determined it would be 54 minutes from the Smith Center, 42 minutes from Carolina North and 35 minutes from Odum Village. The latter would have access to existing parking decks.
The school consulted schools such as Kansas (Allen Fieldhouse), Kentucky (Rupp Arena), and Texas (Moody Center).
“We’ve talked to a lot of them,” Steinbacher said. “It’s helpful and informative, but nobody is Carolina basketball. Nobody is the University of North Carolina.”
Steinbacher said the research now aligns under a clear mission to “do what’s best for Carolina basketball while maximizing what it provides to the Carolina athletics department and the University community.”
Each option has been evaluated against six core priorities. Does it:
— Deliver the premier basketball-first arena in college sports?
— Preserve Carolina basketball’s legacy?
— Provide elite training facilities for both programs?
— Improve and expand student seating?
— Offer a top-tier fan experience?
— Sustain long-term revenue for basketball and 26 additional varsity sports?
Athletic Director Bubba Cunningham has emphasized that broad support will be necessary for a project expected to cost between $600 million and $800 million.
“The students, alumni and season ticket holders — it’s the whole community,” Cunningham said in a UNC release. “There’s emotion, logic and finance. Now we’re getting to the logic and finance.”
UNC leaders are now consulting with trustees, donors, student groups, and a council of 11 former Carolina players as they move closer to a recommendation.
“This process is very different from the early 1980s,” said executive associate athletic director Steve Newmark in a UNC release, referring to the move from Carmichael to the Smith Center. “Times have changed, and we’re adapting.”
Subscribe to read Tar Heel Tribune ad-free
Subscribe for a cleaner, smoother reading experience without the flashing banners, slow-loading elements, or those especially annoying pop‑up ads that interrupt the flow of the story. You’ll also get the first version of each story emailed to you. The only ads you’ll see are static, non-intrusive ads for UNC‑related books, and there are none currently on the site.
Photo courtesy of UNC Athletics
