After morning hearing, judge to rule today on Fens’ request for temporary restraining order

Cameron Fens is cleared to practice with the team even though he is in eligibility limbo.

By R.L. Bynum

An Orange County Superior Court judge said she would rule Thursday afternoon on North Carolina center Cameron Fens’ request for a temporary restraining order that could allow him to make his Tar Heels debut Friday against Marshall.

Judge Alyson Grine heard arguments for about 74 minutes Thursday morning in a Webex hearing, a day after Fens sued the NCAA. The 7-foot graduate transfer from South Dakota has practiced and traveled with Carolina but missed its first four regular-season games.

“We’re here today to request a temporary restraining order that will allow one player, Mr. Fens, to play until the court hears our preliminary injunction motion on full briefing,” Fens attorney Samuel Hartzell (below photo) told Grine.

Fens joined the hearing with attorney Ripley Rand. His parents, Randy and Ginny, also attended. Thomas Woodrow of Holland & Knight argued for the NCAA.

Whether Fens plays Friday could depend on how broadly Grine writes any order she grants. In a sworn statement, UNC coach Michael Malone said Carolina would certify Fens’ eligibility if the order also shields the school and Fens’ individual records from NCAA penalties tied to his participation

“Cameron is ready to play now. I will play him in our first game after he is certified,” Malone wrote.

Fens’ attorneys offered two independent grounds for letting him play. Hartzell argued that the NCAA’s new five-year eligibility rule covers Fens because he first enrolled in college in August 2022.

The NCAA says players who had already used four seasons before the rule took effect Aug. 1 remain ineligible. Hartzell told Grine that the NCAA’s own rules require changes in wording to be written into the legislation and that the bylaw contains no such exclusion.


Subscribe for a cleaner, smoother reading experience without the flashing banners, slow-loading elements, or those especially annoying pop‑up ads that interrupt the flow of the story. You’ll also get the first version of each story emailed to you. The only ads you’ll see are static, non-intrusive ads for UNC‑related books, and there are none currently on the site.


— Read Fens’ lawsuit against NCAA, affidavits from Malone, doctor
—
Dixon helps Arizona topple No. 3 UConn; Jackson (22) and Henderson (career-high 16) lead routs
—
Tar Heels in the pros: Ingram goes 20–20, Ryan and Nance power comeback; 19 for White


Grine asked Woodrow why the NCAA had left the exclusion out of the bylaw. Woodrow initially said he expected it to appear in the next version of the rules, then said he did not know whether it would. Hartzell pointed to that shift in his rebuttal.

The second argument concerns a medical hardship waiver. According to the lawsuit, Fens hurt his right foot in South Dakota’s seventh game of the 2024–25 season and played 12 more games before an MRI revealed a stress fracture. A foot and ankle surgeon said in a sworn statement that Fens would have missed the rest of the season if the fracture had been diagnosed when he first hurt the foot.

The NCAA denied the waiver Oct. 20, and South Dakota appealed. Grine asked why Fens was seeking a court order when the NCAA could rule in his favor as soon as Friday.

After Hartzell finished his opening argument, Grine reached for a familiar Carolina basketball line. In their brief, Fens’ attorneys wrote that “the clearance is the misdiagnosis,” arguing that South Dakota cleared him to keep playing because its medical staff mistook a stress fracture for a soft-tissue injury.

“I’m not sure that’s going to be as catchy on a T-shirt as ‘the ceiling is the roof,’ but I understand your position,” Grine said, invoking Michael Jordan’s line from halftime of UNC’s win over Duke at the Smith Center on March 4, 2017.

Hartzell acknowledged that possibility and said the appeal addresses only the waiver. Grine also questioned why NCAA rules leave it to a school to pursue a waiver on a player’s behalf. In Fens’ case, that school was South Dakota.

Woodrow urged Grine to deny the request, arguing that the court lacks jurisdiction and that Fens’ contract claims are unlikely to succeed. He said the rules in place during Fens’ first four seasons governed his eligibility and that the new rule applies going forward.

He also cited the Tennessee case in which Fens obtained an injunction that an appeals court later put on hold, and argued that Fens had known for more than a year that his eligibility was in question. Hartzell said the North Carolina suit raises different claims.

“This emergency has been manufactured not by the NCAA, but by the plaintiff,” Woodrow said. He noted that NCAA staff had told South Dakota on Nov. 13 to expect an appeal decision by Nov. 20.

“The schedule is the emergency, Your Honor,” Hartzell said, pointing to Friday’s game against Marshall and next week’s game against West Virginia, which has fifth-year players on its roster.

Before adjourning, Grine said she wanted to review legal authorities Woodrow had cited before ruling. Hartzell asked her to waive any bond, arguing that the NCAA would suffer no financial harm. Woodrow said he wanted to consult his client. Grine said the week of Nov. 30 would work better than Thanksgiving week for a follow-up hearing if she grants the temporary order. She did not set a date.

Midway through the hearing, an unidentified participant interrupted with an expletive urging the court to let Fens play. Grine instructed the moderator to remove the person and warned that anyone disrupting the proceeding could be held in contempt and jailed for up to 30 days.

Carolina hosts Marshall at 9 p.m. Friday at the Smith Center on ACC Network.

Photo via @UNC_Basketball

Leave a Reply