By R.L. Bynum
An Orange County Superior Court judge granted emergency relief from the NCAA on Thursday, allowing North Carolina center Cameron Fens to play while his eligibility case proceeds, meaning the South Dakota transfer will likely make his Tar Heels debut Friday against Marshall.
Judge Alyson Grine issued the temporary restraining order after hearing arguments Thursday morning, a day after Fens sued the NCAA. The 7-foot graduate transfer has practiced with Carolina and traveled with the team but missed its first four regular-season games.
He’ll be eligible until Nov. 30, when a hearing on a preliminary injunction will be heard.
The hearing, which lasted a little more than an hour, was conducted via WebEx. Fens’s parents, Randy and Ginny, attended, along with Fens’s attorney, Samuel Hartzell (below photo), and Thomas Woodrow of Holland & Knight, who represented the NCAA. Fens joined the hearing with attorney Ripley Rand.

“We’re here today to request a temporary restraining order that will allow one player, Mr. Fens, to play until the court hears our preliminary injunction motion on full briefing,” Hartzell told Grine.
Fens’s lawsuit made two arguments for why he should be able to play. His attorneys say the NCAA’s new five-year eligibility rule covers him because he first enrolled in college in August 2022. They argue the NCAA is relying on language outside the bylaw itself to exclude athletes who used four seasons before the new rule took effect Aug. 1. Hartzell told the judge the NCAA’s own rules require a change in a bylaw’s wording to be codified, and that no such change has been written into the rule.
In a sworn statement filed in support of Fens, UNC coach Michael Malone said Carolina would certify Fens’s eligibility if the order also protects the school and Fens’s individual records from NCAA penalties tied to his participation.
“Cameron is ready to play now. I will play him in our first game after he is certified,” Malone wrote in an affidavit.
Fens was also seeking to regain a season through a medical hardship waiver. According to the lawsuit, he injured his right foot in South Dakota’s seventh game of the 2024–25 season and played 12 more games before an MRI revealed a stress fracture. A foot and ankle surgeon said in a sworn statement that Fens would have missed the rest of the season if the fracture had been diagnosed when he first hurt the foot.
The NCAA denied the waiver Oct. 20. South Dakota appealed, and NCAA staff told the school to expect a decision by Friday, according to the filing. Grine asked why Fens was seeking court intervention before the NCAA ruled on that appeal, noting that the subcommittee could decide in his favor as soon as Friday. Hartzell acknowledged that was possible but said a favorable waiver decision would not resolve the separate five-year argument.
Subscribe to read Tar Heel Tribune ad-free
Subscribe for a cleaner, smoother reading experience without the flashing banners, slow-loading elements, or those especially annoying pop‑up ads that interrupt the flow of the story. You’ll also get the first version of each story emailed to you. The only ads you’ll see are static, non-intrusive ads for UNC‑related books, and there are none currently on the site.
More on Tar Heels
— Read Fens’ lawsuit against NCAA, affidavits from Malone, doctor
— Dixon helps Arizona topple No. 3 UConn; Jackson (22) and Henderson (career-high 16) lead routs
— Tar Heels in the pros: Ingram goes 20–20, Ryan and Nance power comeback; 19 for White
After Hartzell finished his opening argument, Grine reached for a familiar Carolina basketball line. In their brief, Fens’ attorneys wrote that “the clearance is the misdiagnosis,” arguing that South Dakota cleared him to keep playing because its medical staff mistook a stress fracture for a soft-tissue injury.
“I’m not sure that’s going to be as catchy on a T-shirt as ‘the ceiling is the roof,’ but I understand your position,” Grine said, invoking Michael Jordan’s line from halftime of UNC’s win over Duke at the Smith Center on March 4, 2017.
Grine noted that under the NCAA’s process only a school can pursue a waiver, which in this case meant South Dakota, the school where Fens was playing when the injury was missed.
“A strange process where the interested party is the one who has to appeal,” Grine said. Hartzell agreed, saying “this process is a mess right now, and Mr. Fens is the one who’s being caught in the middle of it.”
Woodrow urged the judge to deny the request, arguing that the court lacks personal and subject matter jurisdiction and that Fens’s underlying claims are contract claims that are likely to fail. He said the bylaws in effect during Fens’s four seasons ended his eligibility, and that the new rule applies only going forward.
Woodrow also pointed to Tennessee, where Fens had been a plaintiff in a case in which an injunction was stayed on appeal, and to North Carolina judges who denied similar requests. He called the Tennessee litigation forum shopping and argued that Fens had known about his eligibility problems for more than a year.
“This emergency has been manufactured not by the NCAA, but by the plaintiff,” Woodrow said, noting that NCAA staff had told South Dakota on Nov. 13 to expect a decision by Nov. 20.
Midway through the hearing, an unidentified participant interrupted with an expletive urging the court to let Fens play. Grine instructed the moderator to remove the person and warned that anyone disrupting the proceeding could be held in contempt and jailed for up to 30 days.
Grine also pressed Woodrow on why the NCAA had not written its intended exclusion into the bylaw. Woodrow said he did not know the answer and first told the judge he expected the language to be codified in the next version of the rules, then later said he did not know whether it would be. Hartzell highlighted that shift in his rebuttal.
Hartzell said the urgency is real because the games are being played now. “The schedule is the emergency, Your Honor,” he said, noting that Carolina plays Marshall on Friday and West Virginia in Charlotte a week later, where players from Fens’s class have suited up for the Mountaineers.
Hartzell asked the court to waive a bond, saying the NCAA would suffer no financial harm, and Woodrow said he wanted to confer with his client on that point. The attorneys also discussed a return hearing on the preliminary injunction, and Grine said the week of Nov. 30 would work better than Thanksgiving week. [Insert the order’s specifics, including its duration, any bond and the protections for UNC and Fens’s records.]
Midway through the hearing, an unidentified participant interrupted with an expletive urging the court to let Fens play. Grine instructed the moderator to remove the person and warned that anyone disrupting the proceeding could be held in contempt and jailed for up to 30 days.
Carolina hosts Marshall at 9 p.m. Friday at the Smith Center on ACC Network.
Photo via @UNC_Basketball

1 Comment