Is UNC better off with experienced talent rather than elite young talent?

By R.L. Bynum

Last summer, Coach Hubert Davis worked hard to keep a player and it worked out pretty well even after he was unable to do that.

It’s hard to know now but that pattern may be repeating itself this summer.

Instead of Walker Kessler, a five-star recruit, returning for his sophomore season, the Tar Heels got an impactful fifth college season from Oklahoma transfer Brady Manek. Instead of getting five-star forward G.G. Jackson for one season as a freshman, UNC is getting Northwestern transfer Pete Nance, another player who will play his fifth college season in Chapel Hill.

If Jackson, as expected, enrolls at South Carolina to play next season, he’d be the first player to decommit from UNC and play for another college without extenuating circumstances since Tom McMillan opted to play for Maryland in 1971.

Two other notable commitments in the 2000s went elsewhere. J.R. Smith committed to Carolina in 2003 but decided to go directly to the NBA. JamesOn Curry had his Carolina scholarship offer rescinded in 2004 after he pleaded guilty to drug charges. Curry played at Oklahoma State.

It remains to be seen if Nance can have the same sort of impact as Manek.

Carolina originally expected Jackson to join the program after what would have been his upcoming senior high school season. Had he decided to re-classify before Nance committed to transfer to UNC, Jackson could have played for the Tar Heels next season if Davis agreed to go in that direction.

The question is, given the terrific chemistry of the returning four starters from last season’s Final Four team, would a player such as Jackson, who would likely demand the ball more, have disrupted that chemistry next season?

ESPN ranks Jackson, who averaged 22.1 points and 10.9 rebounds during his junior season in high school, No. 3 in the Class of 2023.

Jackson clearly is talented but recent college basketball history has shown that experienced talent is more valuable in NCAA tournament play than young elite talent.


Duke had four freshmen last season who were first-round NBA draft picks in Paulo Banchero, Mark Williams, A.J. Griffin and Trevor Keels, but that wasn’t enough to overcome an experienced Carolina team in the Final Four.

The 2019 national championship Virginia team started three juniors. When Baylor won the 2021 national title, every starter in the NCAA championship game was an upperclassman. The Kansas team that beat UNC in the NCAA final started three upperclassmen in that game.

Carolina figures to start five upperclassmen next season with at least one and probably two fifth-year players. That’s a big reason that they will be highly ranked in the preseason polls.

Having Jackson for the 2023–23 season would have been huge for Davis considering who he might lose after next season. With Jackson’s change of heart, that wasn’t going to happen.

Carolina might just be better off next season with experienced talent in Nance rather than elite young talent in Jackson had the South Carolina prep star decided to re-classify sooner.

Time will tell.

UNC roster

Jr.RJ DavisPG6–0175
Fr.Seth TrimblePG6–3185
Jr.Caleb Love26–4195
Soph.D’Marco Dunn36–4185
Jr.Puff Johnson36–8205
5th yearLeaky Black36–8200
Soph.Dontrez Styles46–6210
JuniorJustin McKoy46–8220
Fr.Tyler Nickel46–8210
Fr.Jalen Washington46–9210
5th yearPete Nance56–10225
Sr.Armando Bacot56–10240
Fr.Will Shaver56–10265
Soph.Creighton LeboG6–1170
Sr.Jackson WatkinsG6–1175
Jr.Rob LandryG6–4195
Sr.Duwe FarrisF6–6215

Photo via @NUMensBball


1 Comment

  1. Carolina basketball doesn’t need someone who commits to something and then backs out instead of seeing through what he committed to, part of becoming an adult is following through with things you start!! GG talks about wanting to go to a college that’ll show him how to grow from a teenager into a grown man( that’s what Carolina has always done with it’s players in any sport), and following through with commitments is a crucial part of growing into an adult!!! Carolina Basketball will ultimately be better off without GG, I wish him the best and maybe someday he’ll figure this growing up thing out


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s