By R.L. Bynum

After Duke, rather than eventual College Football Playoff finalist Miami, advanced to the ACC title game, the league moved to overhaul the way it resolves ties so the championship matchup better reflects the conference’s two strongest teams.

Commissioner Jim Phillips unveiled the new policy Wednesday at ACC Kickoff in Charlotte, saying the change coincides with the league’s shift to a nine‑game conference schedule and is designed to account for an uneven slate of conference games during the transition.

Phillips noted that the policy was adopted after a “thoughtful data‑driven review by our athletic directors, including the evaluation of more than 10,000 simulated season outcomes.”

Phillips stressed the new approach rests on three core tenets, and he quoted them verbatim:

— “Head-to-head results will always matter most.”
— “No team will be overly rewarded or penalized based on the number of conference games it played.”
— “When head-to-head competition cannot separate tied teams, the team with the strongest overall body of work will earn the opportunity to compete for the ACC Championship and the conference’s automatic qualifier to the College Football Playoff.”

Explaining how the final element will be measured, Phillips said the conference will use an established metric as part of the tiebreaking sequence.

Subscribe to read Tar Heel Tribune ad-free

Subscribe for a cleaner, smoother reading experience without the flashing banners, slow-loading elements, or those especially annoying pop‑up ads that interrupt the flow of the story. You’ll also get the first version of each story emailed to you. The only ads you’ll see are static, non-intrusive ads for UNC‑related books, and there are none currently on the site.

“A team’s success ranking from sports source analytics, we’ve used them in the past, it will be the third element of the tiebreaking system. It’s what the CFP uses,” he said, adding that the goal is to “give an opportunity to place your two best teams.”

The league didn’t take the process lightly, Phillips said, adding that the simulations helped the conference land on a method that rewards head‑to‑head results while still allowing a fair way to separate teams when schedules differ.

“We talked a lot about it, used a lot of consultants, did 10,000 algorithms of different scenarios,” he said, describing the depth of the review.

The timing of the change reflects a one‑year scheduling wrinkle. For 2026, five ACC schools — Boston College, Clemson, Florida State, Georgia Tech and North Carolina — will play eight conference games because of previously scheduled Power‑4 nonconference opponents, while the other 12 programs will play nine ACC games and one Power‑4 nonconference opponent.

Phillips acknowledged the imbalance but said the policy is intended to prevent teams from being “unfairly rewarded or penalized” by the number of conference games they happen to play.

Looking ahead, the commissioner outlined how the schedule will rotate once the conference settles into its 17‑team alignment. Beginning in 2027, one school each season will play an eight‑game conference schedule on a rotating basis and will be required to schedule two Power‑4 nonconference opponents, while the other 16 institutions play nine conference games.

Phillips framed the change as part of a broader effort to protect the integrity of the ACC’s championship and its automatic qualifier to the CFP.

“What’s changed this year is that there’s an AQ awarded for the Power Four conferences. So, you have to do everything you can to position your championship game with those two best teams,” he said, adding that head‑to‑head results will remain the primary determinant but that the conference must also consider “who you play, when you play, the games you win, conference and non‑conference will matter.”

The ACC also moved the title game time to noon on Dec. 6 at Bank of America Stadium, a slot Phillips said will give the conference’s championship “the national spotlight” without competing Power Four games in the same window.

He noted the change in kickoff time was partly practical — “the weather is dicey. It just is. It can be 70, or it could be 38 degrees” — and partly strategic, aimed at maximizing exposure for the league’s top two teams.

Phillips concluded that the new tiebreaker is intended to be “fair, transparent, data‑informed, and assures our game features the two most deserving teams,” and he said full procedural details will be released to the membership and public in the coming days.